Skip to content

America’s marketplace for homes, home services and everything in between.

Home Buying [email protected]

How to Choose a Real Estate Agent: A Buyer’s and Seller’s Checklist

The right real estate agent is part market analyst, part negotiator, and part project manager — and the wrong one costs you money you never see. Most buyers and sellers hire the first agent they meet, usually through a personal referral. Referrals are a fine starting point, but the decision deserves the same comparison shopping you would give any five-figure service. Here is how to choose a real estate agent, backed by what buyers and sellers say actually matters.

What Buyers and Sellers Actually Hire Agents For

In the National Association of REALTORS® 2025 Profile of Home Buyers and Sellers — surveying transactions from July 2024 through June 2025 — 88% of home buyers purchased through a real estate agent or broker. Buyers said they primarily wanted help finding the right home to purchase (50%) and negotiating the terms of the sale (13%), with help on price negotiations (12%) and paperwork (7%) also cited (nar.realtor). Around 43% of buyers chose an agent who was referred to them or whom they had worked with before (NAR 2025 Profile coverage).

Read that list again and use it as a job description: you are hiring for judgment in pricing and negotiation, plus command of the search and the paperwork — not for a lockbox code.

How Agent Representation Works Now

Since August 17, 2024, MLS participants working with buyers must enter into written representation agreements with those buyers, a practice change from NAR’s settlement (nar.realtor). The practical upshot: before touring homes together, you will sign a document spelling out services, length of the agreement, and how your agent is compensated — and compensation is negotiable, not set by law or by any association. Read it, ask about every term, and negotiate what does not fit: the length of the agreement, the areas it covers, and how cancellation works.

Start with Local Proof, Not General Charm

Real estate is intensely local. An agent who is excellent two towns over may misprice your neighborhood. Before interviews, check:

  • Recent transactions in your target area and price band. How many in the last year, how close to asking price, and how many days on market compared with area norms?
  • Reviews and references. Look for patterns in what past clients say about communication, negotiation, and problem-solving — and ask for two recent references you can actually call.
  • Licensing and any disciplinary history. Your state’s real estate regulator publishes license status and actions.
  • Full-time status and bandwidth. Part-time agents can be excellent, but you need to know how quickly they respond during a fast-moving negotiation.

Where you are buying also shapes what to look for. If you are still defining your search, our guide to buying your first home covers the process an agent should be walking you through.

Interview at Least Three Agents

Treat the first meeting as a working session. A good agent will want to understand your goals, timeline, and finances before showing you anything. Questions that expose real differences:

  • “Walk me through your last three transactions in this area.” Specifics reveal familiarity; vague success stories do not.
  • “How do you decide the offer price (or list price)?” You want a comparable-sales methodology, not a gut feel or an inflated number to win the listing.
  • “What will this home’s biggest objections be, and how do you handle them?” Buyers and sellers each need the honest answer about their own situation.
  • “Who else is on your team, and who shows homes or attends inspections?” Know exactly who you will be working with.
  • “How do you handle multiple offers, appraisal gaps, or a bad inspection?” Negotiation scenarios show how they think under pressure — the top skill buyers say they want.
  • “How and how often will you communicate?” Establish the channel and cadence up front; most client complaints are communication complaints.

Ask each candidate to show their work: a recent comparable-sales analysis, a sample marketing plan, or the strategy behind a past negotiation. Verifiable method beats charisma — the agent who can explain exactly why a home sold for what it sold for is the one who will price yours correctly.

Understand the Compensation Conversation

Under the current practice changes, compensation for your agent is negotiable and must be addressed in your written agreement. Typical points of discussion: the rate or fee, what services it includes (professional photography, staging advice, marketing spend), and whether a seller or listing broker will contribute to your agent’s compensation in a given transaction. Compare the full picture: a slightly higher fee with a strong negotiator and a strong marketing plan is often cheaper than a discount agent who costs you price or time. Ask for the numbers in writing, and weigh them against what the agent actually does.

Sellers: Vet the Marketing Plan

If you are listing, the interview should produce a concrete plan: pricing strategy with comparable sales, photography and listing preparation standards, where and how the home will be marketed, and how showings and feedback will be managed. Presentation advice should be specific to your home — see our home improvements that increase property appeal for the projects that typically matter — and consistent with what actually sells in your area. Our guide to selling your house maps the full selling timeline around these decisions.

Red Flags

  • Pressure to sign immediately or to waive protections you asked about.
  • A price opinion that sounds too good — overpricing to win the listing is one of the oldest games in the industry, and it costs sellers both time and final price.
  • Vague answers about the representation agreement or reluctance to explain compensation terms.
  • Poor responsiveness during the interview phase — it will not improve once you are under contract.

Finally, remember the fit factor. You will be in frequent contact through a stressful, weeks-long process. Choose someone who tells you the truth, including when it is inconvenient — the best agents protect clients from bad deals as much as they win good ones.

Frequently Asked Questions

How do I find a good real estate agent near me?

Start with recent transaction activity in your specific neighborhood and price range, then interview at least three candidates. Referrals and online reviews narrow the list; the interview and the comparable-sales methodology decide it. Local professionals in our business directory are another starting point.

Do I have to sign a buyer agreement before touring homes?

Since August 17, 2024, MLS-participating agents working with buyers must have a written representation agreement in place. Read the terms — services, duration, compensation, and cancellation — and negotiate anything that does not fit before you tour.

Are real estate commissions negotiable?

Yes. Agent compensation is not set by law or by any association, and the written agreement is where the terms are stated. Compare what each agent includes — marketing, photography, availability, negotiation experience — against the fee.

Should I use the listing agent to buy a house?

The listing agent represents the seller. Buyers benefit from their own agent whose mandate is your interests, especially in negotiation — the task about 13% of buyers cite as their top need, alongside finding the right home.

What is the most common reason to change agents?

Communication breakdowns and misaligned expectations. Set the cadence and the scope at the start, put the terms in the agreement, and address problems early rather than letting them compound through an escrow.

Share this article

Keep reading