Skip to content

America’s marketplace for homes, home services and everything in between.

Home Guides [email protected]

How to Hire a Contractor: Licenses, Quotes, and Red Flags

Hiring a contractor is one of the highest-stakes transactions a homeowner makes. You are inviting strangers to alter the single largest asset you own, often for sums that run into the tens of thousands of dollars, and the work is largely invisible once walls close and finishes go on. Most contractors are legitimate professionals. The minority who are not cause the stories that make homeowners anxious — and the difference between the two groups is almost always visible in the paperwork before a single hammer swings.

This guide walks through the process end to end: how to build a candidate list, verify credentials, compare quotes on equal terms, structure a contract and payment schedule, and recognize the warning signs that consumer agencies say define home improvement scams. The same principles apply whether you are hiring a roofer, a remodeler, or a general contractor; our guide to finding a reliable roofing contractor applies them to roofing specifically.

Start With a Candidate List, Not a Single Name

Collect three to five candidates before you interview anyone. The best sources are people you know: neighbors whose projects you have seen completed, colleagues, and local tradespeople who work alongside contractors and know who does clean work. Note which neighborhood job sites stay tidy — a clean site is one of the most honest signals of how a crew treats your property.

Online directories and review sites can round out the list, but read reviews critically. Look for detailed accounts — how the crew handled surprises, whether the schedule held — rather than generic five-star praise. A pattern of complaints about liens, unfinished work, or deposit disputes matters more than any single review.

Verify Licenses and Insurance Yourself

The Federal Trade Commission’s consumer guidance on home improvement scams makes the first rule simple: consider only contractors who are licensed and insured, confirm the license with your state or county government, and ask the contractor for proof of insurance (consumer.ftc.gov). Do not take “licensed and bonded” on a business card as evidence. Licensing requirements vary by state and trade — many states license plumbers, electricians, and HVAC technicians at the state level, while general contracting may be licensed or registered at the county or city level. Your state contractor licensing board’s website is the authoritative lookup.

Insurance is separate from licensing and equally important. Ask for a certificate of liability insurance and, for any company with employees, workers’ compensation coverage. An uninsured worker injured on your property can become your liability. Call the insurer listed on the certificate to confirm the policy is current — it takes five minutes and it is the kind of check scammers never expect.

Also check complaint histories. The FTC recommends contacting your state or local consumer protection office and the local Home Builders Association to see whether complaints have been filed against the business, and searching online for the company name alongside words like “complaint” or “scam” (FTC).

Get Multiple Written Estimates — and Compare Them Properly

Get at least three written estimates. The FTC’s standard is explicit: a written estimate should include a description of the work, the materials, the completion date, and the price — and you should not automatically choose the lowest bidder, especially when one bid sits far below the others. Ask for an explanation of any large gap in pricing (FTC). A bid that is dramatically cheaper usually achieves that by leaving out work you will need later: proper underlayment, permits, disposal, or finish-grade carpentry.

Compare bids line by line against a common scope. Are allowances realistic for the fixtures and finishes you want? Is demolition and debris removal included? Who pulls permits and pays fees? What happens when the wall opens and the estimate’s assumptions turn out wrong — is there a written change-order process? If you are pricing a specific project, our cost guides give you the benchmarks: roof replacement costs and kitchen remodeling among them.

Understand how the contractor earns. General contractors commonly work on cost-plus pricing, and HomeAdvisor’s industry cost data shows GC fees for a mid-size home remodel ($20,000 to $75,000 in project cost) running roughly $2,000 to $15,000, while hourly rates range from $50 to $150 when a contractor bills by time (HomeAdvisor). Trade rates vary similarly — electricians typically $50 to $100 per hour, plumbers $45 to $200 per hour depending on complexity (HomeAdvisor). None of these numbers are suspicious on their own; what matters is that the fee structure is written down and you understand what triggers extra charges.

Write a Contract That Protects You

Contract requirements vary by state, but the FTC advises asking for a written agreement even where one is not required, and making sure it includes the contractor’s name, address, phone number, and license number; an estimated start and completion date; and a written statement of your right to cancel within three business days if you signed the contract in your home or anywhere other than the seller’s permanent place of business (FTC).

Beyond those minimums, insist on: a detailed scope (drawings or a specification list, not a one-line description); the materials by brand and model where selection matters; a payment schedule tied to completed milestones; how change orders will be priced and approved; warranty terms on both labor and materials; and who is responsible for permits and inspections. Keep every document — contract, change orders, invoices, lien waivers, permit sign-offs — in one file. That paper trail matters when you sell, as we explain in our guide to selling your house.

Payment Rules That Prevent Disaster

The FTC’s guidance on payments is blunt: do not pay the full amount up front, and note that some states legally limit how large a down payment a contractor may request — check with your state consumer agency for the law where you live (FTC). A reasonable structure is a small deposit to schedule the work, progress payments tied to visible milestones, and a final payment only after your walkthrough and punch-list sign-off.

Pay by check or credit card so there is a record. Never pay in cash to a contractor who will only accept cash — that pairing is one of the FTC’s listed scam signals. If a contractor pushes you to borrow through a lender they know, stop: the FTC describes this as a distinct scam in which homeowners are steered into loans against their home, sometimes signing papers they do not understand. Never agree to financing arranged by the contractor without shopping the loan yourself and reading the terms (FTC).

Red Flags: Walk Away When You See These

The FTC lists the tactics scammers use; every one of these should end the conversation (consumer.ftc.gov):

  • Someone knocks on your door saying they are “in the area” or have materials left over from a previous job.
  • Pressure to decide immediately, sign today, or take a “today only” price.
  • Demands to pay everything up front, or cash-only terms.
  • A request that you obtain the building permits yourself — pulling permits is the contractor’s job and shifts code responsibility onto you.
  • Suggestions that you borrow money from a lender they know, or sign financing papers you have not read.
  • No fixed business address, no verifiable license, no written estimate, or a price far below every other bid.

Managing the Project After You Hire

Stay engaged without hovering. Confirm the permit is posted, keep a running decision log for change orders, and schedule a final walkthrough before the last payment. Take dated photos of work before it is covered by drywall or finishes — future you, and any future inspector, will be grateful. Keep the maintenance schedules for whatever the project touched; our home maintenance checklist is the companion piece to every renovation.

Frequently Asked Questions

How many estimates should I get before hiring a contractor?

At least three written estimates. The FTC specifically recommends multiple written estimates and warns against automatically choosing the lowest bidder. Compare scopes line by line and ask for an explanation whenever one price diverges sharply from the others.

What is a reasonable down payment for a contractor?

Enough to schedule materials and crew — commonly 10% to 30% depending on the project and state law. Some states cap down payments by statute. Never pay the full project price up front, and never deal in cash-only terms; both are red flags identified by the FTC.

How do I verify a contractor’s license?

Look up the license number on your state contractor licensing board’s website — or your county or city building department where licensing is local. Confirm it matches the business name on the contract, is current, and covers the trade being performed. Then ask for a certificate of insurance and call the insurer to confirm it is active.

What should a home improvement contract include?

At minimum: the contractor’s name, address, phone number, and license number; the scope of work and materials; an estimated start and completion date; the total price and payment schedule; and a written statement of your right to cancel within three business days if the contract was signed away from the contractor’s place of business. Add warranty terms and a written change-order process.

Should I use a contractor who offers to arrange financing?

Be very cautious. The FTC describes the contractor-arranged loan as a distinct scam pattern. If the project needs financing, shop lenders yourself, compare the APR and terms, and never sign loan documents you have not read in full.

Share this article

Keep reading